Pushleads | Asheville SEO Services


When Choosing an SEO Company, Keep These Guidelines In Mind

Choosing an SEO company is one of the most important decisions that a business owner can make, so we want to help you choose wisely.

Choosing an SEO Company

Choosing an SEO company is one of the most important decisions that a business owner can make, so we want to help you choose wisely.

Sadly many businesses and brands have suffered at the hands of SEO agencies that gave them little to no return on their investment. Many look and sound the same, making it hard to differentiate the varying levels of expertise and experience.

Follow These Guidelines for Success


Choosing the wrong SEO firm can be costly in terms of money and time lost, so it is necessary to choose the right one. As a company leader, I’ve been concerned with this process for a long time. It might seem self-serving that I’m penning this piece, but let me be the first to admit that I don’t want to work with every firm, nor is my firm the best choice for everyone.

Working on the client side of the table, I have compiled a list of nine pointers to aid you in selecting the appropriate match and firm for your business.

When searching for an SEO agency to work with, consider these tips:

1. Set and achieve objectives.

It’s time to get down to business if you haven’t translated your organizational, sales, and marketing objectives into SEO. Beware of anyone who wants to do SEO for you without discussing the topic first. Good agencies will want to know early on what your objectives are, whether they relate to ROI, conversions, or another measure of success you have in mind.

It’s accurate to say that you shouldn’t expect results from an SEO firm without performing the research yourself, but you should at least know what sort of return on investment you’re looking for. That can include the number of conversions you need or the actions you desire, or you can use industry benchmarks and baseline performance as references.

Be particular about what monetary gain or achievement looks like before you begin your SEO firm search, regardless of your knowledge or lack thereof. It is crucial to have as much of it as possible before commencing your SEO company hunt.

2. Assess internal assets.

Finding an SEO agency has become typical, especially for individuals without internal SEO knowledge or time. You’re probably looking for one because you don’t have the time or resources to succeed. Even if you have the agency complete everything, you will still require specific time commitments and availability for approvals, oversight, feedback, and performance reviews.

When a brand or organization needs SEO, they often hold onto additional aspects or employ other associates to provide everything from content to IT to UX and collaborative aspects. Determine whether your internal team can or should take care of everything or some of the SEO requirements. Collaborate with or hire outside experts to assist you. Doing this can determine whether the firm is suitable for all or some of the SEO elements you will need in the future.

3. Budgeting is essential.

There are specific cost parameters you might be able to locate by examining the combination of objectives and ROI, as well as the resources or preexisting partners you might be able to draw on. If you can get some initial estimates and recognize the arena you’re in, for example, you can move on if the cost is excessively high (or alarmingly low). Even if you want the first number right away, knowing your cost restrictions will allow you to examine agencies sooner and filter out those that are most suitable in size, scope, and fit.

Rather than viewing SEO as an expense line item, it’s often preferable to link it to an ROI ratio. It’s okay not to know anything; it depends on the situation. In the initial strategy or audit phases, be honest about the data you don’t know, ask how the agency can help you reach your goals, and assess the risks associated with different budget levels and investments.


4. Research

When looking at websites, talking to those referring you to potential agencies, or engaging in any initial outreach, be mindful of specific sizes. For example, the size of the agency concerning your firm, or more importantly, how capable they are of serving your company, are both important. The phase of your company’s development and lifecycle may also be critical.

To save time and effort on locating the perfect match, look for an agency that suits your identity and objectives. Some agencies are all-inclusive, taking on any client with a dollar to spare.


Other firms specialize in specific industries or niches, set pricing minimums, target audiences, or even the composition or structure of their teams, for example. Resist pitches from agencies that don’t match your goals or appear out of your league.

You can accomplish this by:

  • Looking for case studies, credentials, references, and thought leadership content.
  • Looking at the variety of clients.

Make sure you research and are prepared to question any contradictions or confusing messages.

5. Prepare for an interview.

I frequently receive excellent queries from prospective clients. Occasionally, I don’t get enough questions, so I respond to queries that I wish had been asked or issues that I believe my potential customers want to know. If you are more organized about the queries you pose, you can make a more objective comparison at the close of the firms you are considering.

Everything necessary to you, whether it’s related to plans or not, can be questioned:

  • Their focus (or elements of #4 above).
  • Their approach.
  • The ways you would work together.

It’s crucial to be well prepared if you require close collaboration between development, copy, or other content and between teams. Furthermore, you should familiarize yourself with your colleagues and identify how our cultures align (or don’t).

Make sure you have a well-thought-out list of questions, note everything necessary, and prepare for every interviewee to ask something different. An objective viewpoint afterward will allow you to give your finalists more detailed information.

6. Evaluate the fit.

Is your team in sync with your agency’s approach to the project? I’m not just referring to you and me, the person leading the initiative (or whatever sales or account representative). I’m referring to those on your team and ours who will work together.

  • How much is hands-on involvement involved?
  • What level of transparency is expected?
  • What about employee retention rates, workforce stability, and team fit?

These issues, in addition to the agency’s approach, are critical. You don’t want to be stalled or lose interest after signing a contract or after a few months of a long-term arrangement.

7. Use your instincts.

Ask difficult questions.

  • Does something seem too fantastic to be true
  • Is there red or yellow warning flags anywhere?

Use your instincts and look more profound if you feel anything is amiss. If you think you don’t match up with the firm, verify it.

Pay attention to your gut instinct when a project doesn’t feel right or isn’t done correctly. You should not push forward if things don’t feel right or are incorrect. I’m not suggesting you run away. Perhaps you’re the first client they’ve ever worked with in your industry or niche. This might be fine if they are open about their approach, research methodology, and risk tolerance. It might be a good idea to work with someone new rather than the cookie-cutter approach everybody else uses in your industry.

You might also like: How to Avoid These Five SEO Mistakes That Can Impact Your Google Ranking.

8. Be aware of the procedure.

Two significant barriers to achieving success goes beyond resource constraints and a lack of sufficient SEO knowledge. Every client has a distinct level of SEO knowledge, an understanding of SEO processes, and an understanding of the company’s unique approaches. We (agency personnel) might take for granted that not everyone is as enthusiastic about the issues as we are.

9. Make sure you understand the agreement terms.

Ensure that you comprehend everything in the contract before you sign it! If you want to know more about SEO, hire an SEO lawyer or advisor. Long-term contracts, sticky cancellation clauses, and work ownership claims are acceptable, but you should know what you are signing up for.

You may get cost savings and commitment from both sides if you have a long-term agreement. SEO takes time, but you should avoid these scenarios:

  • To be held hostage to your work product, content, or properties.
  • It’s frustrating when you work together for a couple of months and then get hit with many change orders.
  • When the agency isn’t covering all aspects of the campaign (such as content, development updates, CRO, etc.).
  • They weren’t defined in clear terms.

An ideal relationship is one in which trust and accountability are balanced over time, and the billing and value remain balanced. After signing the contract, you no longer have to think about it again.

Choosing the appropriate fit SEO firm can be difficult. It may be challenging to get through the clutter of many companies sounding the same, evaluate the experience and expertise, or plan your fit with them. Furthermore, it might lead to wasted time, energy, and money. I hope the suggestions I’ve offered will assist you in preparing and thinking about the procedure in detail so you may discover the proper fit for you.

For SEO audits, click here to book your appointment.

What’s Your SEO Score?

Enter the URL of any landing page or blog article and see how optimized it is for one keyword or phrase.

Share this post