Switching website companies can hurt your SEO, but it doesn’t have to. The damage comes from specific technical mistakes made during migration, not from switching itself. Fix those mistakes before you go live and your rankings stay intact.

Key moments (16)
0:00 Switch Website Companies Without Losing Rankings
0:42 Who this is for
1:07 What You Need Before You Start
1:43 Rankings Drop Fast After a Bad Migration
2:19 Why is a redirect map the most important migration step?
3:06 Migration With vs. Without a Plan
3:47 Step Two: Protect Your Content and Metadata
4:25 What does Google actually track for your domain?
5:17 Step Three: Verify Schema and Local Signals
6:01 Page Speed Is a Ranking Signal You Control
6:47 Step Four: Test Speed Before You Approve Launch
7:22 What should you do the hour after your site launches?
8:12 Recovery Timeline When You Act Fast
8:45 What AI Search Means for Your Migration
9:32 Quick Recap
9:52 See Exactly How Your Site Shows Up Right Now
Full transcript

0:00 Switch Website Companies Without Losing Rankings
Businesses lose thirty to seventy percent of organic traffic after a bad migration. The mistakes are specific and preventable. Switching website companies does not have to hurt your Google rankings. The damage almost every business experiences comes from specific technical mistakes during migration — not from switching itself. This video walks through the exact checklist that protects your organic traffic, your map pack position, and the phone calls you are getting right now. Work through each step before your new site goes live and your rankings stay intact. In the next few minutes, building your redirect map, protecting your content and metadata, and testing speed before launch.

1:07 What You Need Before You Start
Before migration begins, four things need to be in your hands. First, confirm you hold owner-level access to Google Search Console — not just user access. When an old agency leaves, they can take years of performance data if the account is in their name. Second, export every indexed URL from Search Console and run a free crawler like Screaming Frog on your live site. Third, pull twelve months of top-performing pages and search queries. Fourth, run Google PageSpeed Insights on your current site and screenshot the mobile and desktop scores. That is your baseline.

1:43 Rankings Drop Fast After a Bad Migration
Here is what happens when a migration goes wrong. Search Engine Land has documented it repeatedly: businesses lose thirty to seventy percent of organic traffic in weeks after launch, then spend months recovering. BrightLocal data shows local businesses with broken citation links after a redesign can lose map pack visibility in as little as two to three weeks. Google can re-crawl your site within days of launch. Missing redirects can drop traffic inside the first week. Recovery without a plan takes three to nine months. With a plan, you are stable or improved within sixty to ninety days.

2:19 Why is a redirect map the most important migration step?
Why is a redirect map the most important migration step? Step one is building your redirect map — the single most important thing you will do. Export all indexed URLs from Search Console. Run Screaming Frog to catch any pages Search Console missed. Create a two-column spreadsheet: old URL on the left, new destination URL on the right. Prioritize pages earning organic traffic, pages with backlinks, and pages linked in your Google Business Profile. Critical detail: many redirect plugins default to a three-oh-two redirect, which passes little to no ranking value. Every redirect in a migration must be a three-oh-one. Check every URL before launch, not after. Hand this map to your agency in writing and make its delivery a contractual milestone.

3:06 Migration With vs. Without a Plan
Here is what is at stake. Without a plan: old pages return four-oh-four errors within days, backlinks point to dead pages and pass zero ranking value, local schema gets stripped by the new theme, page speed drops twenty to forty points, and Search Console access disappears with the old agency. Recovery takes three to nine months. With a plan: three-oh-one redirects preserve ranking signals immediately, redirects recover link equity for every URL you have earned, schema is verified on staging before launch, speed is fixed before go-live, and ownership is transferred before the switch. You are stable or improved within sixty to ninety days.

3:47 Step Two: Protect Your Content and Metadata
Step two is protecting your content and metadata. Filter your pages in Search Console by organic clicks. Your top twenty pages earn most of your calls — treat them as untouchable. Export every page title and meta description from your current site. The new site should start with those exact titles and descriptions unless your agency has a documented reason to change them. If your agency wants to remove content to make pages look cleaner, flag it. Google is ranking your words, not your design. Wherever you can keep the exact same URL, keep it. Same URL means no redirect needed, eliminating half the SEO risk before any work starts.

4:25 What does Google actually track for your domain?
What does Google actually track for your domain? Your Google rankings are tied to three things your web company does not store in your website files: your URLs, your backlinks, and your trust signals. Change a URL without a redirect and that page starts from zero — all ranking power built over months or years is gone. Backlinks survive a company switch because they point to your domain. But if those backlinks point to pages returning a four-oh-four, they pass no value. Google confirmed in its documentation that three-oh-one redirects pass the majority of link equity. That is why the redirect map is non-negotiable. Structured data — specifically LocalBusiness schema — tells Google your business name, address, phone number, hours, and category in a format machines read perfectly. Get a free AI Visibility Check at the link in the description — from PushLeads.

5:17 Step Three: Verify Schema and Local Signals
Step three is verifying your local signals. Many WordPress themes strip or silently overwrite existing schema markup when you switch. Before launch, run your staging URL through Google’s Rich Results Test and confirm it reads LocalBusiness schema correctly. Check your name, address, and phone number on the contact page and in the footer — the format must match exactly what appears across your directory listings. A designer abbreviating Street to St., or listing a tracking number instead of your main business number, creates a local signal conflict Google factors into map pack rankings. After launch, log into your Google Business Profile and confirm the linked URL is your new primary address.

6:01 Page Speed Is a Ranking Signal You Control
Page speed is a ranking signal, and a redesign is the most common moment it drops. Google has used Core Web Vitals as a ranking factor since twenty twenty-one. It measures how fast main content loads, how quickly the page responds to input, and how much the layout shifts while loading. A mobile score above seventy is generally safe. A mobile score below fifty is a problem. The four things that tank mobile speed most often are uncompressed images, too many fonts, unoptimized JavaScript, and third-party chat or marketing scripts that load before the page content. A beautiful new website that loads slowly will rank below an ugly website that loads fast, all else being equal.

6:47 Step Four: Test Speed Before You Approve Launch
Step four is testing speed before you approve the final design. Run PageSpeed Insights on your live site and screenshot the results. Then run the same tool on the staging site. Compare mobile scores side by side. If the new site scores lower, do not approve launch. Send Google’s specific flagged issues back to the agency. Fixing them takes a few hours of technical work, not a full redesign. Put the speed requirement in writing before you sign the contract. Ask your agency to show you mobile and desktop PageSpeed scores on the staging site as a deliverable — not a courtesy.

7:22 What should you do the hour after your site launches?
What should you do the hour after your site launches? Step five is the Search Console handoff and your post-launch sequence. Transfer Search Console ownership to yourself using an internal email address you will always control — owner level, not user level. If you are moving to a new domain, use the Change of Address tool. If staying on the same domain, the redirect map and sitemap submission do the job. Within the first hour after launch, submit your new XML sitemap in Search Console. Use the URL Inspection tool to request manual indexing for your top ten pages. Test every major old URL by confirming it lands on the correct new page, not a four-oh-four. Monitor Search Console daily for two weeks. Any traffic drop in the first few days is almost always a redirect or indexing issue — fixable fast if you catch it early.

8:12 Recovery Timeline When You Act Fast
How fast you act after launch determines how fast you recover. Fix broken redirects within the first two weeks and most businesses recover lost traffic within four to six weeks once Google re-crawls the pages. With a full migration plan in place before launch, you are stable or improved within sixty to ninety days. Every week a four-oh-four error sits unfixed is another week Google treats that page as deleted. BrightLocal research shows fixing broken citation links and schema quickly significantly shortens the recovery window for local map pack rankings.

8:45 What AI Search Means for Your Migration
One more reason this matters: AI search. Google’s AI Overviews, ChatGPT, and Perplexity now pull business information directly from websites and Business Profiles to answer questions like who is the best roofer near me. If your website goes dark during migration, pages return errors, or content gets thinned in a redesign, AI tools stop pulling your business as an answer. Schema markup helps significantly. When your site correctly identifies your business type, services, location, and hours in structured data, that information is more machine-readable and more likely to appear in AI-generated results. It is not just your Google rankings at stake — it is whether AI tools include you in answers at all.

9:32 Quick Recap
Quick recap. Map every old URL to a new destination with a three-oh-one redirect before launch. Keep your top page titles, descriptions, and URLs unchanged unless there is a documented reason. Test mobile PageSpeed on staging and do not approve launch if the score drops. Act fast and rankings stay intact.

9:52 See Exactly How Your Site Shows Up Right Now
Before you sign any contract with a new web company, you need a clear picture of exactly what you are protecting. Which pages are driving your calls right now. Which URLs carry the most link equity. What your speed scores actually are. That is exactly what a pre-migration audit shows you — and it is what PushLeads builds for local service businesses before a single line of code changes. See exactly how your business shows up in Google and AI search with a free AI Visibility Check. Get the link in the description, or call eight two eight, three four eight, seven six eight six.

▶ Watch it hereMore videos →

whether switching website companies or rebuilding your website hurts your Google rankings, what actually causes ranking drops in a redesign or migration, and the checklist to protect your calls before you switch

What Actually Happens to Your Rankings When You Switch

Your Google rankings aren’t stored in your website files. They’re tied to your URLs, your content, your backlinks, and the trust signals Google has built up over time for your domain. When you switch website companies, none of that disappears automatically. What disappears is the connection between your old pages and your new pages, if nobody builds that connection on purpose.

Google indexes specific URLs. If your old site had a page at /services/roof-repair and your new site puts that same content at /roofing/residential/repair, Google treats those as two different pages. The old URL loses its ranking. The new URL starts from zero. That’s the core problem behind almost every ranking drop after a redesign.

Search Engine Land has documented this pattern repeatedly. Businesses lose 30 to 70 percent of organic traffic in the weeks after a launch, then spend months trying to recover. The recovery is possible, but it takes work that should have happened before launch.

Does changing web design companies automatically reset your SEO?

No. Your domain authority, your backlinks, and your indexed content all survive a company change. What doesn’t survive automatically is your URL structure, your metadata, your schema markup, and your page speed scores. Those require active protection. If the new company handles them correctly, your rankings should hold steady or improve within 60 to 90 days of launch.

How fast do rankings drop after a bad migration?

Google can re-crawl your site within days of a launch. If redirects are missing, you can see traffic drop inside the first week. BrightLocal data shows that local businesses with broken citation links after a redesign can lose map pack visibility in as little as two to three weeks. The speed of the drop depends on how often Google was crawling your site before the switch.

The Real Causes of SEO Drops During a Website Redesign

Most ranking drops after a redesign come from one or more of six specific problems. Knowing these in advance lets you demand your new agency prevents them.

Six causes of SEO ranking drops during a website redesign
Most ranking drops after a redesign come from one or more of six specific problems.

The first cause is missing 301 redirects. A 301 redirect tells Google that an old URL has permanently moved to a new URL. Without it, Google sees the old page as gone and the new page as brand new. You lose all the ranking power the old page earned.

The second cause is rewritten or deleted content. Some agencies strip out content during a redesign to make pages look cleaner. If that content included your target keywords, your topical relevance drops. Google is ranking your words, not your design.

The third cause is slower page speed. A new design often means heavier images, more JavaScript, and third-party scripts. Google has used Core Web Vitals as a ranking factor since 2021. A site that goes from a 90 performance score to a 55 will feel that in rankings.

What happens to my backlinks when I switch website companies?

Your backlinks survive the switch because they point to your domain, not your web design company. But if your URLs change and you don’t redirect them, those backlinks point to dead pages. A link to a dead page passes no value. Google confirmed in its documentation that 301 redirects pass the majority of link equity, so a proper redirect preserves the value of every backlink you’ve earned.

Can a new website design improve my SEO?

Yes, it can. A redesign that improves page speed, mobile usability, internal linking, and content structure can produce noticeable ranking gains within 60 to 90 days. The key is that SEO improvements need to be a planned goal of the redesign, not an afterthought. Ask any new agency to show you their pre-launch SEO checklist before you sign a contract.

Want more customers from Google & AI search?

Get a free SEO audit of your site — see exactly what to fix first.

Get My Free Audit Book a Call

301 Redirects: The Single Most Important Step

If you do nothing else before switching, build a redirect map. A redirect map is a spreadsheet that lists every old URL on the left and the most relevant new URL on the right. When the new site goes live, every old URL sends visitors and Google directly to the right new page.

To build this list, go to Google Search Console and export all indexed URLs. You can also use a free crawler like Screaming Frog to pull every page on your current site. This gives you a complete picture of what needs to be redirected.

Prioritize pages in this order. First, any page that gets organic search traffic right now. Second, any page with backlinks pointing to it. Third, any page that appears in your Google Business Profile links or local citations. Those three categories cover the highest-risk URLs.

What’s the difference between a 301 and a 302 redirect?

A 301 tells Google the move is permanent. It passes ranking signals to the new page. A 302 tells Google the move is temporary and passes little to no ranking value. During a website migration, every redirect should be a 301. Many content management systems default to 302 when you install a redirect plugin. Check the redirect type on every URL before launch, not after.

whether switching website companies or rebuilding your website hurts your Google rankings, what actually causes ranking drops in a redesign or migration, and the checklist to protect your calls before you switch in practice

Google Search Console Setup Before You Switch

Google Search Console is free and it’s the most direct window into how Google sees your site. Before you switch companies, take these four steps.

First, verify that you have owner-level access to your Search Console account, not just user access. When you switch companies, the old agency may have been the property owner. If they leave, you can lose access to years of performance data.

Second, export your top performing queries from the last 12 months. This list tells you which keywords are sending you traffic right now. You need to make sure the new site has content that targets every one of these terms.

Third, export your top performing pages. These are the pages you absolutely cannot afford to lose or break during migration.

Fourth, after the new site launches, submit your XML sitemap in Search Console and request indexing for your most important pages. This speeds up how fast Google discovers your new URL structure.

Should I tell Google I’m switching website companies?

Google doesn’t have a form for that. What you do instead is use the Change of Address tool in Search Console if you’re also moving to a new domain. If you’re staying on the same domain, the redirect map and sitemap submission do the same job. Google will figure it out through crawling, but submitting the sitemap manually speeds the process up by days or weeks.

Local SEO Signals You Must Protect During a Switch

If your business depends on Google Maps rankings or the local pack, you have additional signals to protect beyond your website URLs. BrightLocal research shows that NAP consistency, meaning your name, address, and phone number matching exactly across your website and all directories, is one of the most consistent local ranking factors.

Many website redesigns accidentally change the format of the NAP on the contact page or in the footer. The new designer might abbreviate Street to St., or list a tracking phone number instead of the main business number. Each small inconsistency creates a signal conflict that Google factors into local rankings.

Schema markup is the other local signal most redesigns break. Schema.org defines a structured data format called LocalBusiness schema. When properly coded into your site, it tells Google your business name, address, phone, hours, and category in a format machines read perfectly. Many new WordPress themes or page builders strip or overwrite existing schema. Confirm with your new agency that LocalBusiness schema is in the new site before launch.

Will my Google Business Profile be affected when I switch web companies?

Your Google Business Profile is separate from your website and your web company has no access to it unless you gave them access. The profile itself won’t change. What can change is the website URL linked in your profile. After launch, log into your Google Business Profile and update the website link to your new primary URL. If the URL stayed the same, you don’t need to do anything.

Page Speed and Core Web Vitals: Don’t Trade Rankings for Design

Google’s Core Web Vitals measure three things: how fast the main content loads, how quickly the page responds to user input, and how much the layout shifts while loading. These scores are ranking signals. A beautiful new website that loads slowly will rank below an ugly website that loads fast, all else being equal.

Before approving a new design, run the demo site through Google’s PageSpeed Insights tool. Look at the mobile score specifically. Mobile scores below 50 are a problem. Scores above 70 are generally safe. The main things that tank mobile speed are uncompressed images, too many fonts, unoptimized JavaScript, and third-party chat or marketing scripts that load before the page content.

Ask your new agency to give you PageSpeed scores on mobile and desktop before you approve the final design. Put that requirement in writing.

How do I compare my current site speed to the new one?

Run Google PageSpeed Insights on your current live site and screenshot the scores. Then run it on the staging site your new company builds. Compare mobile scores side by side. If the new site scores lower, ask the agency to fix the specific issues Google flags before you approve launch. This takes a few hours of technical work, not a full redesign.

SEO risk comparison switching website companies with and without a migration plan
Businesses lose 30 to 70 percent of organic traffic in the weeks after a launch when no migration plan exists.
SEO Risk Comparison: Switching Website Companies With vs. Without a Migration Plan
Factor No Migration Plan With Migration Plan
URL changes Old pages return 404 errors, rankings drop within days 301 redirects preserve ranking signals immediately
Backlinks Links point to dead pages, pass no value Redirects recover link equity for every URL
Local schema Often stripped by new theme, local visibility drops Schema verified before launch, no visibility loss
Page speed Heavy new design may score 20-40 points lower Speed tested on staging, issues fixed before go-live
Search Console data Access lost if old agency owned the property Ownership transferred before switch, data preserved
Keyword targeting Content rewritten without SEO review, rankings lost Top queries exported and matched to new pages
Recovery timeline 3 to 9 months to recover lost traffic Stable or improved within 60 to 90 days

The Pre-Launch Checklist to Protect Your Calls and Leads

This checklist covers the steps that protect the organic traffic and phone calls you’re getting right now. Work through it before the new site goes live, not after.

Step 1. Export all indexed URLs from Google Search Console and your current sitemap. This is your complete list of pages that need redirects if their URLs change.

Step 2. Identify your top 20 organic landing pages by traffic in Search Console. These pages are your highest priority. Confirm their content and URLs are preserved exactly, or that perfect redirects exist.

Step 3. Build a redirect map. For every URL that changes, write the old URL and the new destination URL in a spreadsheet. Give this to your new agency and confirm all redirects are 301s.

Step 4. Copy your existing metadata. Export page titles and meta descriptions from your current site. The new site should start with these exact titles unless the new agency has a documented reason to change them.

Step 5. Verify LocalBusiness schema is in the new site. Use Google’s Rich Results Test tool on the staging URL to confirm it reads correctly.

Step 6. Test page speed on mobile before launch. Get a baseline from your current site and confirm the new site matches or beats it.

Step 7. Transfer Search Console ownership to yourself or a trusted internal email address. Don’t leave it in the old agency’s hands.

Step 8. After launch, submit the new sitemap in Search Console and request indexing for your top 10 pages manually.

Step 9. Monitor rankings and organic traffic daily for the first two weeks post-launch. Any drop that appears in the first few days is almost always a redirect or indexing issue, and it’s fixable fast if you catch it early.

How long should I wait before switching website companies?

There’s no required waiting period. You can switch any time, but do the migration planning first, before you sign the new contract. That way the new agency knows from day one that SEO protection is a deliverable, not an optional add-on. Build the redirect map, the content audit, and the speed baseline before the new agency starts building anything.

Questions to Ask Any New Website Company Before You Sign

Not every web design company understands SEO migration. Some excellent designers have never thought about 301 redirects or Core Web Vitals. That’s not necessarily a dealbreaker, but you need to know going in. Ask these questions before you commit.

Ask: Do you build a redirect map as part of every website migration? If they don’t know what a redirect map is, that’s a red flag.

Ask: Will you maintain my existing URL structure where possible? A good agency tries to keep the same URLs unless there’s a strong reason to change them.

Ask: How do you handle metadata during a migration? The answer should include something about preserving existing titles and descriptions as a starting point.

Ask: What is your process for testing page speed before launch? They should test on mobile and use Google PageSpeed Insights or Lighthouse.

Ask: Will you set up and verify Google Search Console on the new site? This is a basic step, but many agencies skip it.

Ask: Do you include LocalBusiness schema markup? Local businesses need this. If they look confused, assume they won’t do it without specific instructions.

What if my current website company owns my domain or hosting?

This is a common and costly situation. Before you switch, confirm you own your domain registration, not your current agency. Log into your domain registrar directly. If the domain is in the agency’s account, request a transfer before you cancel your contract. The same applies to hosting. Some agencies hold domains or accounts as leverage. Getting locked out of your own domain after a switch can take weeks to resolve and will tank your SEO in the meantime.

What to Do If Your Rankings Already Dropped After a Switch

If you switched recently and you’re watching your traffic fall, there’s a clear recovery sequence. Start with the most likely cause first.

Open Google Search Console and go to the Coverage report. Look for 404 errors. Each 404 is a broken page that used to rank. Create a 301 redirect from each broken URL to the most relevant page on your new site. This alone often recovers 50 to 80 percent of lost traffic within four to six weeks once Google re-crawls the pages.

Next, check your top lost keywords in Search Console under the Performance tab. Filter by pages to see which new URLs are ranking for those keywords. If a keyword used to go to /services/plumbing and now it’s going nowhere, that’s a redirect problem or a content problem.

Then run your site through a free crawler and look for duplicate content, missing title tags, and pages accidentally set to noindex. Some website platforms set staging pages to noindex during development and forget to change the setting before launch.

In this video

  1. 0:00 Who Owns Your Digital Assets
  2. 0:37 Four Ownership Questions to Ask First
  3. 1:53 Contract Terms and Exit Clauses
  4. 2:34 Reports That Show Real Business Results
  5. 3:27 GA4 and Search Console Access
  6. 4:03 Competitor Conflicts in Your Market
  7. 4:47 Who Actually Does the Work
  8. 5:36 Ownership Failure Case Study
  9. 6:38 AI Overviews Claims What to Ask
  10. 7:44 Red Flags That Should Stop You
  11. 8:44 Three Numbers Every Client Should Track

Full transcript: What questions should I ask an SEO agency before I sign?

Finally, check your page speed scores and compare them to your pre-launch baseline. If speed dropped significantly, that’s a contributing factor, though usually not the primary cause of rapid traffic loss.

How long does it take to recover from an SEO drop after a website migration?

With prompt action, most businesses recover within 60 to 120 days. The key variable is how fast you identify and fix the specific broken URLs. Every week a 404 error sits unfixed is another week Google treats that page as gone. If you fix redirects in the first two weeks after launch, recovery can happen in four to six weeks. If the errors sit for months, recovery takes longer because Google needs more time to recrawl and re-evaluate each URL.

How AI Search Changes the Stakes for Your Website

Google’s AI Overviews and tools like ChatGPT and Perplexity now pull business information directly from websites and business profiles to answer user questions. If your website goes dark during a migration, if your pages return errors, or if your content gets thinned out in a redesign, AI tools stop pulling your business as an answer.

This matters for local service businesses especially. AI tools increasingly answer questions like “who is the best roofer near me” or “find a dentist accepting new patients” by pulling from structured data, Google Business Profiles, and high-quality website content. A website migration that breaks your structured data or removes detailed service content can reduce your visibility in AI-generated answers, not just in traditional search results.

The fix is the same as for traditional SEO: preserve your content, protect your URLs, verify your schema, and maintain your Google Business Profile. But the reason to care has expanded. It’s not just your Google rankings at stake. It’s whether AI tools include you in answers at all.

Does my website content affect what AI tools say about my business?

Yes. AI tools like Google’s AI Overviews cite and pull from indexed web pages. If your pages are well-structured, specific, and accurate, AI tools are more likely to cite your business in relevant answers. Schema markup helps significantly. When your site correctly identifies your business type, services, location, and hours in structured data, that information is more machine-readable and more likely to appear in AI-generated results.

How PushLeads Approaches Website Migrations

PushLeads works with local service businesses that have already been burned by a website switch that hurt their rankings. The process starts with a full audit of what the current site is ranking for, which URLs matter most, and where the existing site has technical gaps. That audit becomes the blueprint for the migration.

Every URL that changes gets a 301 redirect. Every piece of ranking content gets preserved or improved. Schema markup goes in before launch, not after. Page speed gets tested and hit above 70 on mobile before the site goes live. And after launch, PushLeads monitors Search Console daily for the first two weeks to catch any issues before they compound.

The goal is simple: you should rank the same or better 90 days after switching, not worse.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will switching website companies hurt my Google rankings?

It won’t hurt them automatically. Rankings drop because of specific technical mistakes during migration, not because you changed companies. The most common mistakes are missing 301 redirects, deleted content, broken schema markup, and slower page speed. If your new web company handles all four of those correctly before launch, your rankings should stay stable or improve within 60 to 90 days. The company you switch to matters less than the migration process they follow.

What is the biggest SEO risk when rebuilding a website?

Missing 301 redirects is the single biggest risk. When URLs change and no redirect exists, Google treats the old pages as deleted and the new pages as brand new. You lose all the ranking power those old pages built up over months or years. A complete redirect map, built before launch and tested after launch, prevents most of the SEO damage that businesses experience after a redesign. Every other risk is secondary to getting redirects right.

How do I know if my website migration hurt my SEO?

Open Google Search Console and look at the Performance report. Filter by date and compare organic clicks and impressions from the two weeks before launch to the two weeks after. A drop of more than 15 to 20 percent in that window usually signals a migration problem. Then check the Coverage report for 404 errors. If you see a spike in 404s after launch, those are broken pages that need redirects. Fix them as fast as possible to minimize ranking loss.

Should I keep my old URLs when I rebuild my website?

Yes, whenever possible. Keeping the same URLs is the safest option because it eliminates the need for redirects entirely. Sometimes URL changes are unavoidable, like moving from a platform that used numeric IDs to one that uses words. But if your current URLs are readable and logical, tell your new agency to preserve them exactly. This one decision can eliminate half the SEO risk in a migration before any work even starts.

How long does it take for Google to re-index a new website?

Google can begin re-crawling a site within days of launch, especially for domains it already crawls regularly. Full re-indexing of all pages typically takes two to four weeks. You can speed this up by submitting a fresh XML sitemap in Google Search Console immediately after launch and requesting indexing for your most important pages manually through the URL Inspection tool. Don’t wait for Google to find your new pages on its own.

Can I switch website platforms without losing SEO?

Yes. Businesses switch between WordPress, Squarespace, Wix, Webflow, and custom platforms without losing rankings when the migration is planned correctly. The platform itself is not a ranking factor. What matters is that your URLs either stay the same or get properly redirected, your content is preserved, your page speed stays strong, and your structured data is correctly implemented on the new platform. Platform migrations require extra planning but are not inherently more risky than redesigns on the same platform.

What should I do immediately after my new website launches?

Do these five things in the first 48 hours. Submit your new sitemap in Google Search Console. Request manual indexing for your top 10 pages. Test all major old URLs to confirm redirects are working. Run Google PageSpeed Insights on your homepage and top service pages. Check that your Google Business Profile links to the correct URL. Then monitor Search Console traffic daily for the first two weeks and fix any 404 errors that appear within 24 hours of discovering them.

Does switching website companies affect my Google Business Profile ranking?

Not directly. Your Google Business Profile is a separate asset from your website. But your website content and the URL linked in your profile do influence local rankings. BrightLocal research consistently shows that the website linked from a Google Business Profile contributes to local pack rankings. If your new site has weaker content, slower speed, or missing schema compared to the old one, that can indirectly weaken your map pack position over time. Keep your profile URL updated after launch.

See How Your Business Shows Up Right Now

You shouldn’t guess whether a website switch will hurt your rankings. You need a clear picture of what you’re ranking for today, which pages matter most, and what risks a migration would create for your specific site. That’s exactly what a pre-migration audit shows you.

See exactly how your business shows up in Google and AI search with a free AI Visibility Check at pushleads.com/check or call 828-348-7686.


Want more customers from Google & AI search?

Get a free SEO audit of your site — see exactly what to fix first.

Get My Free Audit Book a Call

Up next

SEO Analytics and Reporting Research Report: Measuring Success That Actually Drives Business Results

27 min read · This comprehensive research reveals that 91% of organizations report SEO positively impacts website performance, yet the traditional metrics we've relied on for decades are…

Want this done for you?

Scan your site. See the gaps. Decide with numbers.

  • Rankings, Google Business Profile and site-speed teardown
  • Report lands in your inbox in about a minute
  • No obligation · 4.9 from 67 Google reviews

Prefer a human? Book 20 minutes with Jeremy

Continue reading