You can’t dispute bad LSA leads anymore. Here’s how you can stop paying for junk calls before they hit your account.
Read the full written guide: Google Local Service Ads for Contractors: The Complete Audit Guide to Eliminating Junk Leads and Attracting Ready-to-Book Customers
Full transcript
0:00
You can’t dispute bad LSA leads anymore. Here’s how you can stop paying for junk calls before they hit your account. That’s the whole answer up front. Google removed the manual dispute button back in July 2024, and there was no opt -out. So the money has saved before the lead is charged, not after. Video walks you through exactly how to do that. The short answer. You have two jobs now. First, cut the junk before it reaches you. Second, rate what does reach you, disputing after the fact is gone. Prevention and rating are the only levers you have left. Everything else in this video is one of those two levers. What’s changed in 2024? Before July 2024, when you got a bad lead, you clicked dispute and made your case, and Google reviewed it, created it, and sometimes didn’t. Starting in July 2024, Google moved every LSA adds advertiser to automated lead remove the manual dispute option entirely. You cannot get it back. Google’s system now reviews every lead automatically and credits the ones it judges in valid. Credits show up in your account balance within about 30 days. A Google representative said that Google now credits more leads overall than when advertisers dispute manually. At the same time, many advertisers report worse lead quality since the change. Both things can still be true. More credits does not automatically mean better leads. It means the bar for what gets charged may have shifted.
1:32
This is the environment you’re operating in right now. What Google still credits? Google still credits leads and determines are invalid on its own review. Spam and wrong numbers are the clearest if Google system flags it, you get the credit automatically. You do not need to do anything except watch your account balance and make sure credits are showing up over time. The 30 day window matters. Credits can take up to about 30 days to show up, so if you’re not checking your account monthly, you may not catch problems. Rate your leads inside that same window. More on that in a few minutes. What Google no longer credits. This is the part that costs you money if you miss it. Leads for a job type you do not offer. Non credit eligible leads from an area outside of your service area zone, not credit eligible calls from existing customers, not credited either. That was reported in March of 2026. Read that again. If a past customer calls you through your LSA listing, Google charges you for that lead and will not credit it back. That means especially for restoration companies where repeat customers and referrals mix into the same call volume. The implication is direct. Your service area settings and your job type lists are now your primary financial defense. Getting those right is not operational. Fix one, tighten your job types. Go into your LSA dashboard right now and look at every job type you have checked. Ask one question for each one. Did we book and complete a job of this type in the last 90 days? If the answer is no, uncheck it.
3:03
Do not leave job types checked because you might take that call someday. Every unchecked type that stays checked is a category of lead that you will pay for and cannot get credit back. For restoration companies, this is especially important. Mold, biohazard, and specialty categories attract calls from people who may not qualify for your services are outside your licensing or need a referral. If you are not actively booking that work, turn it off. Same logic applies to commercial versus residential, metal roofing, TPO, and similar specialities. Only carry job types that match work you are actively closing. Fix two, tighten your service area. Your service area in LSA is not just a marketing decision, billing, boundary. Leads from outside your service area are not credit eligible, so if your radius is set to wide, you will pay for calls from towns you will never drive to. Pull up your area settings, draw it tighter than you think you need to, because you can always expand later. A lead from 60 miles out that you declined to send a truck to is a lead that you paid for with no path to a credit. Shrink the zone to match exactly where you booked jobs. Check the zip codes or cities you may include a one by one. Remove everywhere that you have not booked a job in the last six months. Fix three, rate every lead within 30 days. Where the dispute button used to be, there is now a rate this lead option. Google says it uses your ratings as feedback to improve its automated system.
4:33
Rate every lead, do it within 30 days. Good lead, bad leads, and does not matter. Rate everything. A few practical points. Set a weekly reminder block to your LSA dashboard and rate all leads from the past seven days. Do not let them pile up. If you go past 30 days on a lead, that window is close. You will have no recourse on it and no feedback submitted. Rating consistently is the closest thing you have to what disputing a lead used to be. It is not guarantee of a credit, but is the only direct input you can give Google system about your lead quality. Fix four, answer and screen your calls fast. This one is simple and often skipped. Answer your LSA calls. An unanswered emergency call is a lost job, and you cannot screen or rate a job you never heard. So when you answer, screen the call in the first 30 seconds. Existing customer, make a note. Outside your area, make a note. Wrong job type, make a note. You need that information when you rate the lead later. If you use a CRM or even a call, log spreadsheet, log the lead source, the call outcome, and whether it turned into a booked job. That fees, fix five, fix five, track LSA next to calls and forms. Here’s where it gets real. I want to show you how we track this for a restoration company we work with in North with Arkansas. I’m using their data with permission. Their restoration log 29 LSA leads out of 82 leads in the 30 days between October 18th and November 16th of 2026.
6:03
That is roughly one in four leads coming in from LSA. When you have that number sitting next to your call log and your form submissions, you can see your actual cost per book job, not just cost per lead. Cost per lead is what Google shows you. Cost per job is what determines whether LSA earns its budget. To calculate it, take what you spent on LSA in a month divided by the number of booked jobs that came from LSA leads. And that is your real number. If that number is higher than what you pay from other channels, LSA has a problem. If it is lower, LSA is working. You cannot see any of this if you’re not tracking lead source all the way through to the book job. Set up a simple sheet if you have to source date outcome. That is the minimums. When LSA is no longer worth it, here’s an honest question I want to ask you. If you have tightened your job types, tightened your service area, rated every lead, answered calls fast, and you’re still paying more per brick job through LSA than other channels, LSA may not deserve your budget right now. And that is not a failure. That is a business decision. LSA is on the right channel for every contractor at every time. LSA itself is moving into Google ads and I cover about what to do that in a separate video. So I’ll not go deep on that here. The point is LSA should earn a spot in your budget every month. The tracking in fix five is how you hold it accountable. What to do this week? Here is your action list. One, log into your LSA dashboard and audit your job types. Uncheck everything that you’re not actively booking.
7:35
Two, check your service area, remove any city or zip code where you have not booked a job in six months. Three, rate every unrated lead from the past 30 days right now. Four, set a weekly 15 -minute calendar block to rate new leads before they age out. Five, start logging LSA leads along your calls and forms you can calculate cost per per job next month. That is five things and none of them cost you money. All of them protect the money that you are already spending. If you want to second eyes on your LSA setup and how it fits into your overall lead strategy, you can get your free AI visibility check at PushLeads .com slash check or call us at 828 -348 -7686 and we’ll look at exactly what you have and honestly tell you what we see.
Up next
LSA is moving into Google Ads. What should restoration and roofing owners do?
10:53Google Ads Spend Up, Calls Stopped? How to Diagnose It (Real Case)
5:42Why Your Google Ads Geo-Targeting Is Wasting Your Budget
13:25What should a roofing company actually pay per lead from Google Ads?
12:21Should a garage door company run Google Ads or invest in Google Maps SEO first?
13:16Junk Removal Google Ads: Campaign Strategy With Real Cost DataKeep Reading
Want more customers from Google & AI search?
Get a free SEO audit of your site — see exactly what to fix first.
