Key moments (10)
0:15 What You Actually Buy With a Shared Lead
0:42 Exclusive vs Shared Lead Math
1:41 Why 8 Percent Close Rate Is Realistic
2:13 Volume Buying Does Not Fix the Problem
2:57 Foundation Repair Needs Trust Not Competition
3:46 Speed-to-Answer Is Not a Real Solution
4:42 When Shared Leads Are Acceptable
5:09 Organic Search as an Exclusive Lead Source
6:08 AI Visibility and What Foundation Companies Miss
No, they usually are not and the math is the reason why. A $35 shared lid sounds like a deal until you run the numbers and those numbers flip fast.
Want it done for you? See our local SEO services.
Read the full written guide: Emergency Foundation Repair Marketing: How to Win High-Ticket Jobs Before Competitors Show Up
Full transcript
0:00 Shared Leads Rarely Worth It
No, they usually are not and the math is the reason why. A $35 shared lid sounds like a deal until you run the numbers and those numbers flip fast. Let me show you exactly how that works.
0:15 What You Actually Buy With a Shared Lead
When you buy a shared lead, you are not buying a customer. You are buying a chance to compete for a customer someone else already found. Mignona puts it plainly, your lead goes to three to five companies at the same time it hits your phone. Every one of those companies is calling, texting and chasing the same homeowner you just paid for. That is not a lead. That is a race you already started behind.
0:42 Exclusive vs Shared Lead Math
Shared leads for foundation repair typically run around $35, exclusive leads run higher, often around $90. $90 sounds like more money. $35 sounds like a smarter buy. That instinct is wrong and I will prove it. Here is the math Mignona laid out and I think every foundation repair owner needs to hear this at least once. Take a $90 exclusive lead. You close roughly 30% of those because you are the only company calling. That means you spend about $300 to win one job. Now take a $35 shared lead. You are racing three to five other companies. Your close rate drops to around 8%. Run that math and you spend about $437 per job. The cheap lead costs you $137 more per close job than the expensive one. That gap adds up fast when you are running any real volume of leads.
1:41 Why 8 Percent Close Rate Is Realistic
8% it sounds dramatic. It is not. Think about what the homeowner experiences. They filled out a form within two minutes. Their phone rings four times from four different companies. They feel sold to not helped. They start ignoring calls. They go with whoever they already knew or whoever answered first on a lucky timing. You can be a great company and still lose just because you were caller number two by 30 seconds. That is the shared lead environment.
2:13 Volume Buying Does Not Fix the Problem
A lot of owners try to solve this by buying more shared leads. If I buy 50 leads instead of 20, I will close more jobs. You will close more jobs, but you are a company buying 50 shared leads a month at $35 each. That is $1750 in lead spend. At 8% close, that is four jobs. That same $1750 in exclusive leads at $90 each gets you about 19 leads. At 30% close, that is about six jobs. More jobs, same budget. That is the math in a real scenario.
2:57 Foundation Repair Needs Trust Not Competition
Exclusive does not just mean you are the only caller. It means the conversation starts differently. The homeowner is not braced for a sales fight. They are waiting to hear from someone who can help. That changes your close rate, your average job size, and how much time your team spends chasing ghosts. This matters more in foundation repair than in a lot of other trades. Foundation work is a high ticket, high anxiety purchase. The homeowner is scared. They found a crack or a shifting door or water in the basement. They need to trust someone fast. Trust does not get built when four companies are firing competing pitches at them in the same 15 -minute window. You need space to actually talk to that person. Shared leads do not give you space. One
3:46 Speed-to-Answer Is Not a Real Solution
argument for shared leads is speed. If you answer first, you win the lead. Some companies invest heavily in speed to answer specifically to work the shared lead model. The problem is you are still paying for all the leads you do not answer first. You cannot answer first every time. Your staff is human. You have installs running, calls dropping, bad timing moments. The shared lead model punishes any gap in your response speed with a wasted spend. The $35 price is what you see on the invoice. Here is what the invoice does not show. Staff time chasing leads that ghost you follow up calls and texts across a week for a contact who went with someone else three hours after they inquired. Frustration on your sales team that hits morale over time. Those costs are real even if they never hit a line item.
4:42 When Shared Leads Are Acceptable
I want to be fair here. Shared leads are not automatically worthless in every situation. If you are brand new, have zero pipeline and need any activity to practice your sales process, they can get you reps. If you are testing a new market or service area and you just want to hear real home owner objections, they can provide that signal cheaply. But as a primary lead source for a company doing real volume, the math says no.
5:09 Organic Search as an Exclusive Lead Source
The goal is to build a lead source that is organic search does that. A homeowner and Tampa searching foundation repair near me clicks your listing and calls you. No other company paid for that lead. No race. No competing call. That is as exclusive as it gets. The investment is in the asset, not the transaction. You build it once and it keeps delivering without a per lead fee eating your margin. Emergency foundation repair is a specific keyword category that shows up in search data. Search is like emergency foundation repair in markets like Dallas carry intent that is as urgent as anything in the trades. That person is not comparing three quotes. They are calling the first credible result they find. If you rank for those terms, those calls are yours and only yours. No shared lead vendor is in that equation.
6:08 AI Visibility and What Foundation Companies Miss
Here is a newer layer. Most foundation repair companies are not thinking about yet. A growing number of homeowners are starting their search in AI tools. They ask something like what is the best foundation repair company near me. The AI responds with recommendations. If your company is not visible in that layer, you do not exist for that homeowner. No amount of shared lead buying fixes that exclusive search presence, strong content, and AI visibility work together. Shared leads do none of that. Stop doing the math per lead. Start doing the math per job acquired. Pull your last three months of shared lead invoices. Count the leads. Count the jobs you close. Divide your total spend by jobs close. Compare that number to what you would spend on an exclusive lead source at a 30% close rate. That math will tell you everything. If you want to know exactly where your company stands, get your free AI visibility check. Go to PushLeads .com slash check or call 828 -348 -7686. Look at how visible you are in search and in AI tools right now and we show you where the gaps are. No pitch, just data. Go to PushLeads .com slash check.
Up next
10:50Before You Buy Water Damage Leads, Know the Real Cost
9:42After Hours Answering Service vs Voicemail: Which Costs Less?
12:23Why Roofing Leads Cost More on Google LSA Than Any Other Trade
9:354 Factors That Change How Much Mold Remediation Costs
10:09Before You Drop Price on High-Ticket Jobs
11:34How much does SEO for a roofing company cost?Keep Reading
Want more customers from Google & AI search?
Get a free SEO audit of your site — see exactly what to fix first.
