Tier Upgrade ROI Calculator
Run the same math the video uses to see whether moving to a higher agency tier makes financial sense for your shop.
This is the difference in influenced revenue minus the difference in agency spend — the same math the video runs: at 30 leads closing 40% at $3,000 average that’s $36,000 influenced; at 80 leads it’s $96,000 — a $60,000 difference against only $1,300 more in spend.
Red Flags & Readiness Check
Score your current agency relationship — or vet a new one — against the warning signs and must-haves the video calls out.
Pick your situation
Jump to the part of the video that answers it.
Just starting out on a tight budget · 0:50Small business ready to grow · 1:34Figuring out if the cost is worth it · 4:54Spotting agency red flags · 6:32Running the numbers on a tier upgrade · 7:310:00 Intro
0:22 Why Package Pricing Is All Over the Map
1:32 Tier One: The Starter Package (Five Hundred to Fifteen Hundred a Month)
2:21 Tier Two: The Growth Package (Fifteen Hundred to Three Thousand Five Hundred a Month)
3:20 Tier Three: Aggressive Growth (Three Thousand Five Hundred to Seven Thousand a Month)
4:13 Tier Four: Enterprise or Full-Service (Seven Thousand and Up)
4:56 The Three Numbers That Actually Matter
5:41 What Compensation Models Look Like Beyond Flat Retainers
6:33 Red Flags at Every Tier
7:27 A Worked Example: How the Math Plays Out
8:37 How to Evaluate a Package Before You Sign
9:18 What to Do Right Now
Full transcript
0:00 Intro
Most agencies charge somewhere between five hundred and ten thousand dollars a month, depending on the tier, and the difference in what you actually get is massive. I'm gonna break that down for you today tier by tier with real numbers and honest ROI expectations at each level. No fluff, no "it depends" and "call us." Let's get into it.
0:22 Why Package Pricing Is All Over the Map
The reason you see such a wide range is that digital marketing is not one service. It's a bundle. SEO, paid search, content, social, reputation management, website work, tracking, reporting. Some agencies sell you two of those things and call it a package. Others sell you all eight and still charge the same price. So before you compare prices, you need to know what's actually in the box. That's what this video is for. In my experience, most agency pricing clusters into four buckets. Tier one, starter, roughly five hundred to fifteen hundred a month. Tier two, growth, roughly fifteen hundred to three thousand five hundred a month. Tier three, aggressive, roughly three thousand five hundred to seven thousand a month. Tier four, enterprise or full service, seven thousand and up, sometimes ten thousand or more. Those numbers are industry ballpark based on what I see in the market and what our own clients have come from. Each tier has a different scope, a different timeline to results, and a very different ROI expectation. Let's go through each one.
1:32 Tier One: The Starter Package (Five Hundred to Fifteen Hundred a Month)
At this level, you are typically getting one or two services, usually basic on-page SEO, maybe a little content, maybe a Google Business Profile setup. You are not getting a full-time strategist. You are not getting active paid search management. You are probably not getting conversion tracking that actually closes the loop on revenue. ROI expectation at this tier, slow and modest. Think six to twelve months before you see meaningful organic movement. If your average job is worth three hundred dollars, this might pencil out. If you're a restoration contractor and your average job is eight thousand dollars, you are leaving money on the table staying at this tier. Common mistake at tier one, paying for it and then switching agencies after three months because it's not working. Organic SEO takes time.
2:21 Tier Two: The Growth Package (Fifteen Hundred to Three Thousand Five Hundred a Month)
If you signed up for it, give it the runway it needs. This is where things start to make sense for most small businesses. At this tier, a good agency is running active SEO, some paid search or Local Services Ads, content creation, and reporting that actually means something. Timeline to results drops. You might see traction in three to six months. ROI expectation, positive if your close rate and average ticket are solid. Picture a typical garage door company doing around fifty calls a month. If their cost per call from organic is running forty dollars and this tier gets that to twenty-five dollars, the math on even ten extra calls a month is significant. That kind of improvement is possible at tier two. Not guaranteed, but in a typical case, yes. The key at this tier is accountability. You should be getting a monthly report that shows calls, leads, cost per lead, and revenue influence. If your agency at this tier can't tell you your cost per lead, that's a red flag.
3:20 Tier Three: Aggressive Growth (Three Thousand Five Hundred to Seven Thousand a Month)
Now we're talking a real team, dedicated strategists, active paid search with real budget optimization, ongoing technical SEO, link building, content, reputation management, and conversion rate work on your site. Timeline to results. You should see movement in thirty to ninety days on paid and meaningful organic gains in four to six months. ROI expectation at this tier. This is where revenue positive campaigns live for service businesses doing real volume. Restoration companies, HVAC contractors, law firms, healthcare practices, anyone where one new client is worth thousands of dollars. This tier makes sense. The risk at tier three, paying for it with a website that converts at one percent. If your site sends everyone to a contact form that nobody fills out, even the best traffic strategy won't save you. Fix the conversion problem first or alongside the traffic work.
4:13 Tier Four: Enterprise or Full-Service (Seven Thousand and Up)
At this level, you're getting either a very large scope or a very competitive market or both. Multi-location businesses, franchises, companies going after high competition keywords in major metros. The agency is functioning as your outsourced marketing department. You get strategy, execution, creative paid media management, analytics, and often integrations with your CRM or call tracking platform. ROI expectation. Enterprise budgets require enterprise revenue. If your business does under a million a year, you probably don't need this tier yet. If you're at five million and growing, this is where you stop piecing things together and start running a real marketing operation. Forget the monthly retainer for a second.
4:56 The Three Numbers That Actually Matter
The three numbers that determine whether any package is worth it are these. Number one, cost per lead. What does it actually cost to generate one inbound call or form fill? Number two, close rate. What percentage of those leads do you actually close? Number three, average ticket or lifetime value. What is a closed customer worth to you? If your cost per lead is sixty dollars, you close thirty percent and your average job is four thousand dollars. The math is obvious. If your cost per lead is sixty dollars, you close five percent and your average job is two hundred dollars, no agency tier will save that business model. Know your numbers before you sign a contract.
5:41 What Compensation Models Look Like Beyond Flat Retainers
Not every agency charges a flat monthly fee. Some agencies charge performance-based, meaning you pay per lead or per call. Some charge a percentage of ad spend, typically ten to twenty percent industry ballpark. Some do hybrid models, a lower base retainer plus a performance kicker. Each model has trade-offs. Flat retainer is predictable, but the agency gets paid whether results are good or bad. Performance-based aligns incentives but can get expensive fast if volume is high. Percentage of spend keeps the agency motivated to scale what's working, but can create pressure to increase your ad budget even when it doesn't make sense. Ask any agency you talk to, "How do you make more money if I make more money?" The answer tells you a lot about how they'll behave. A few red flags show up regardless of price point.
6:33 Red Flags at Every Tier
First, look for clear reporting on your cost per lead. If you cannot see that figure every month, walk away. Watch out for lock-in contracts longer than twelve months. You should not need to sign for two years to test anything. That is especially true for a five hundred dollar a month retainer. Some agencies sell impressions as their primary success metric. Impressions do not pay your rent. Leads and revenue are what actually matter. Be cautious of any guaranteed first page rankings promise. Nobody can guarantee rankings, and anyone claiming otherwise is misleading you. They may also be planning tactics that get your site penalized. Vague scope in a contract is another serious warning sign. If it just says social media management, that tells you almost nothing. You need to know how many posts are included. You also need to know which platforms and what content strategy applies. Without those details, you are essentially signing a blank check.
7:27 A Worked Example: How the Math Plays Out
Here is how the math works for a typical shop. They handle around one hundred calls a month. Currently, they run tier one at twelve hundred dollars a month. That tier generates around thirty leads from digital. The cost per lead comes out to forty dollars. Now they move up to tier two at twenty-five hundred a month. Paid search gets added to the mix at that tier. Leads jump to eighty a month at that point. The new cost per lead is thirty-one dollars a month. That works out to an additional twenty-five cents per lead. Their close rate holds steady at forty percent. The average ticket sits at three thousand dollars. At thirty leads, they close twelve jobs. Those twelve closes influence thirty-six thousand in revenue. At eighty leads, they close thirty-two jobs. Those thirty-two closes influence ninety-six thousand in revenue. The difference in agency spend is thirteen hundred a month. The difference in influenced revenue is sixty thousand a month. That is not a guaranteed outcome for every shop. Every market is different, and every close rate is different. Run this math before deciding a higher tier costs too much. Ask for a sample report before you sign anything.
8:37 How to Evaluate a Package Before You Sign
If the agency can't show you what your reporting will look like, that's a red flag. Ask who specifically will work on your account, not just the company. Ask what tools they use for tracking. Call tracking, Google Analytics for a CRM integration. Know the stack. Ask for references from businesses in your industry or a comparable industry. Ask what the first thirty days look like. A good agency has a clear onboarding process, not a we'll get started handshake. And ask, what does success look like at ninety days, six months, one year? If they can't answer that with specifics, they don't have a real strategy. They have a template. If you're trying to figure out which tier is right for your business,
9:18 What to Do Right Now
the fastest way is to know where you actually stand online right now. Not where you think you stand, where you actually stand. We do a free visibility teardown that shows you your current organic footprint, your paid search exposure if you're running ads, and where the gaps are compared to whoever is beating you in your market. No pitch, no pressure. You walk away with real data. Go to SEO.PushLeads.com/audit and get yours, or call us directly at eight two eight three four eight seven six eight six. Talk soon.
Most agencies charge somewhere between five hundred and ten thousand dollars a month, depending on the tier, and the difference in what you actually get is massive. I'm gonna break that down for you today tier by tier with real numbers and honest ROI expectations at each level.
Read the full written guide: What Do Digital Marketing Packages Actually Cost in 2026?
Up next
Browse all 325 videos →
10:16How much does restoration company software actually cost?
10:16How much does Google Business Profile optimization cost to outsource versus doing it yourself?
11:07is buying restoration leads from lead brokers ever worth it?
10:21Managed Repair Programs for Restoration: Worth It?
9:59How much does radon testing cost?
10:51How do restoration companies win premium jobs instead of competing on price against every lowballer?Keep Reading
Want more customers from Google & AI search?
Get a free SEO audit of your site — see exactly what to fix first.
