TL;DR: Packages exist to make buying easy and delivery predictable. Both are legitimate. The problem is that tiering usually varies volume, not strategy — so the $5,000 tier is the $2,000 tier with more posts, whether or not more posts is what you need. Three questions expose that quickly.
Full transcript
Section 1
Most agencies charge somewhere between $510,000 a month, depending on the tier, and the difference in what you actually get is massive. I’m going to break that down for you today, tier by tier, with real numbers and honest ROI expectations at each level. No fluff, no it depends and call us. Let’s get into it.
Section 2
it. The reason you see such a wide range is that digital marketing is not one service.
Section 3
It’s a bundle. SEO, paid search, content, social, reputation management, website work,
Section 4
tracking, reporting. Some agencies sell you two of those things and call it a package.
Section 5
Others sell you all eight and still charge the same price. So before you compare prices,
Section 6
you need to know what’s actually in the box. That’s what this video is for.
Section 7
In my experience, most agency pricing clusters into four buckets.
Section 8
Tier 1, starter, roughly $500 to $1,500 a month.
Section 9
Tier 2, growth, roughly $1,500 to $3,500 a month.
Section 10
Tier 3, aggressive, roughly $3,500 to $7,000 a month.
Section 11
Tier 4, enterprise or full service, $7,000 and up, sometimes $10,000 or more.
Section 12
those numbers are industry ballpark based on what I see in the market and
Section 13
what our own clients have come from each tier has a different scope a different
Section 14
timeline to results and a very different ROI expectation let’s go through each
Section 15
one at this level you are typically getting one or two services usually
Section 16
basic on-page SEO maybe a little content maybe a Google business profile setup
Section 17
up you are not getting a full-time strategist you are not getting active paid search management
Section 18
you are probably not getting conversion tracking that actually closes the loop on revenue
Section 19
roi expectation at this tier slow and modest think six to twelve months before you see meaningful
Section 20
organic movement if your average job is worth three hundred dollars this might pencil out
Section 21
if you’re a restoration contractor and your average job is eight thousand dollars you are
Section 22
are leaving money on the table staying at this tier. Common mistake at tier one, paying for it
Section 23
and then switching agencies after three months because it’s not working. Organic SEO takes time.
Section 24
If you signed up for it, give it the runway it needs. This is where things start to make sense
Section 25
for most small businesses. At this tier, a good agency is running active SEO, some paid search or
Section 26
local service ads, content creation, and reporting that actually means something. Timeline to results
Section 27
drops you might see traction in three to six months ROI expectation positive if
Section 28
your close rate and average ticket are solid picture a typical garage door
Section 29
company doing around 50 calls a month if their cost per call from organic is
Section 30
running $40 and this tier gets that to $25 the math on even 10 extra calls a
Section 31
month is significant that kind of improvement is possible at tier 2 not
Section 32
Not guaranteed, but in a typical case, yes.
Section 33
The key at this tier is accountability.
Section 34
You should be getting a monthly report that shows calls, leads, cost per lead, and revenue influence.
Section 35
If your agency at this tier can’t tell you your cost per lead, that’s a red flag.
Section 36
Now we’re talking a real team, dedicated strategists, active paid search with real budget optimization,
Section 37
ongoing technical SEO, link building content, reputation management, and conversion rate work on your site.
Section 38
Timeline to results.
Section 39
You should see movement in 30-90 days on paid and meaningful organic gains in 4-6 months.
Section 40
ROI expectation at this tier.
Section 41
This is where revenue positive campaigns live for service businesses doing real volume.
Section 42
Restoration companies, HVAC contractors, law firms, healthcare practices, anyone where one new client is worth thousands of dollars.
Section 43
This tier makes sense.
Section 44
The risk at tier 3, paying for it with a website that converts at 1%.
Section 45
If your site sends everyone to a contact form that nobody fills out, even the best traffic strategy won’t save you.
Section 46
Fix the conversion problem first or alongside the traffic work.
Section 47
At this level, you’re getting either a very large scope or a very competitive market or both.
Section 48
Multi-location businesses, franchises, companies going after high competition keywords in major metros.
Section 49
The agency is functioning as your outsourced marketing department.
Section 50
you get strategy execution creative paid media management analytics and often
Section 51
integrations with your CRM or call tracking platform ROI expectation
Section 52
enterprise budgets require enterprise revenue if your business does under a
Section 53
million a year you probably don’t need this tier yet if you’re at five million
Section 54
and growing this is where you stop piecing things together and start
Section 55
running a real marketing operation forget the monthly retainer for a second
Section 56
Second, the three numbers that determine whether any package is worth it are these.
Section 57
Number one, cost per lead.
Section 58
What does it actually cost to generate one inbound call or form fill?
Section 59
Number two, close rate.
Section 60
What percentage of those leads do you actually close?
Section 61
Number three, average ticket or lifetime value.
Section 62
What is a closed customer worth to you?
Section 63
if your cost per lead is $60 you close 30% and your average job is $4,000 the
Section 64
math is obvious if your cost per lead is $60 you close 5% and your average job is
Section 65
$200 no agency tier will save that business model know your numbers before
Section 66
you sign a contract not every agency charges a flat monthly fee some agencies
Section 67
Agencies charge performance-based, meaning you pay per lead or per call.
Section 68
Some charge a percentage of ad spend, typically 10% to 20% industry ballpark.
Section 69
Some do hybrid models, a lower base retainer plus a performance kicker.
Section 70
Each model has trade-offs.
Section 71
Flat retainer is predictable, but the agency gets paid whether results are good or bad.
Section 72
Performance-based aligns incentives but can get expensive fast if volume is high.
Section 73
percentage of spend keeps the agency motivated to scale what’s working but
Section 74
can create pressure to increase your ad budget even when it doesn’t make sense
Section 75
ask any agency you talk to how do you make more money if I make more money the
Section 76
answer tells you a lot about how they’ll behave a few red flags show up
Section 77
regardless of price point first look for clear reporting on your cost per lead if
Section 78
you cannot see that figure every month walk away watch out for lock and
Section 79
contracts longer than 12 months. You should not need to sign for two years to test anything.
Section 80
That is especially true for a $500 a month retainer. Some agencies sell impressions as
Section 81
their primary success metric. Impressions do not pay your rent. Leads and revenue are what
Section 82
actually matter. Be cautious of any guaranteed first page rankings promise. Nobody can guarantee
Section 83
rankings and anyone claiming otherwise is misleading you. They may also be planning
Section 84
tactics that get your site penalized vague scope and a contract is another
Section 85
serious warning sign if it just says social media management that tells you
Section 86
almost nothing you need to know how many posts are included you also need to know
Section 87
which platforms and what content strategy applies without those details
Section 88
you are essentially signing a blank check here is how the math works for a
Section 89
typical shop they handle around 100 calls a month currently they run tier 1
Section 90
at $1,200 a month. That tier generates around 30 leads from digital. The cost per lead comes out to
Section 91
$40. Now they move up to tier two at $2,500 a month. Paid search gets added to the mix at that
Section 92
tier. Leads jump to $80 a month at that point. The new cost per lead is $31 a month. That works out
Section 93
to an additional $0.25 per lead. Their close rate holds steady at 40%. The average ticket sits at
Section 94
$3,000. At 30 leads, they closed 12 jobs. Those 12 closes influenced $36,000 in revenue. At 80
Section 95
leads, they closed 32 jobs. Those 32 closes influenced $96,000 in revenue. The difference
Section 96
in agency spend is $1,300 a month. The difference in influence revenue is $60,000 a month. That is
Section 97
not a guaranteed outcome for every shop. Every market is different and every close rate is
Section 98
different run this math before deciding a higher tier cost too much ask for a sample report before
Section 99
you sign anything if the agency can’t show you what your reporting will look like that’s a red
Section 100
flag ask who specifically will work on your account not just the company ask what tools they
Section 101
use for tracking call tracking google analytics for a crm integration know the stack ask for
Section 102
references from businesses in your industry or a comparable industry, ask what the first 30 days
Section 103
look like. A good agency has a clear onboarding process, not a we’ll get started handshake and
Section 104
ask what does success look like at 90 days, six months, one year. If they can’t answer that with
Section 105
specifics, they don’t have a real strategy. They have a template. If you’re trying to figure out
Section 106
which tier is right for your business, the fastest way is to know where you actually stand online
Section 107
line right now. Not where you think you stand, where you actually stand. We do a free visibility
Section 108
teardown that shows you your current organic footprint, your paid search exposure if you’re
Section 109
running ads, and where the gaps are compared to whoever is beating you in your market.
Section 110
No pitch, no pressure. You walk away with real data. Go to seo.pushleads.com slash audit and
Section 111
get yours or call us directly at 828-348-7686. Talk soon.
Table of Contents
Want it done for you? See our local SEO services.
- Why agencies package at all
- What tiering usually hides
- Three questions that expose a thin package
- Package versus custom scope
- A fair comparison worksheet
- What we do instead
Why Agencies Package At All
Packaging isn’t a scam. It solves three real problems.
For the buyer, it removes decision paralysis. Most business owners don’t want to specify a marketing scope; they want to pick one and get going.
In this video
- 0:00 What a Real Agency Quote Includes
- 0:38 Line Item Format Explained
- 1:16 Three Numbers to Demand Upfront
- 2:52 SEO Section Must-Have Line Items
- 3:30 Blog Content Specificity Red Flags
- 4:22 Vague Language That Hides Accountability
- 4:53 Reporting Section What to Require
- 5:32 How Much to Budget Each Month
- 6:15 Garage Door Company Budget Breakdown
- 7:04 Comparing Two Quotes Side by Side
- 7:50 Questions to Ask Before You Sign
- 8:28 Visibility Audit Before Any Retainer
Show transcript
A real agency quote lists every deliverable as its own line item with a price attached. If yours doesn’t, you’re probably overpaying for work you can’t verify.
Most small businesses hand over a retainer check every month and get back a PDF with phrases like "ongoing optimization" and "content strategy support." Those phrases mean nothing without numbers behind them. This video gives you a checklist you can use to read any agency quote, compare two agencies side by side, and spot the line items that signal a serious vendor versus one that’s padding the bill.
A line item quote breaks your monthly spend into individual rows. Each row names one service. Each row shows the unit, the quantity, and the price. Think of it like a contractor’s bid for a bathroom remodel. You don’t just see a total number. You see tile labor, demo work, fixture installation, and permits all listed separately. A marketing quote should work the same way. You should be able to point to any row and ask: what exactly happens here, how many times per month, and how do I verify it? If an agency can’t answer those three questions for every line, that’s your first red flag.
Here are the three numbers I look for before anything else.
Number one: keyword count per page. How many keywords is the agency planning to target on each page of your website? The right answer is roughly one to three focused keywords per page, occasionally up to five on a longer page. If an agency says they’re targeting 20 keywords on your homepage, that’s not strategy — that’s noise. In my experience, the pages that rank are the ones built around one primary keyword and a tight cluster of two or three supporting terms. Get the keyword count in writing.
Number two: keyword density, or percentage. Your primary keyword on any given page should appear naturally, not be stuffed. A common guideline is around 1% of total word count. So on a 500-word page, you’d expect to see your target phrase used roughly five times. Some agencies promise full optimization without ever committing to what that means. If the quote doesn’t name a target density or at least a review process, push back.
Number three: total organic keywords being actively targeted site-wide. This is the number I see ignored most often. Ask the agency: across my whole website, how many organic keywords are you managing and tracking? For a small local business, in my experience, a focused agency is actively watching somewhere between 30 and 150 keywords. Broader than that and you’re often looking at vanity reporting. Narrower than that and you’re paying for very light work. Get the number.
Here’s what should show up as its own row in the SEO section of any quote. Keyword research is one row. On-page optimization is one row. Blog content production is one row, with the number of posts per month written out. Technical SEO or site health audits should be their own row. Local ranking tracking should be its own row. Link building or citation work should be named and priced separately. If all of that is bundled under "SEO services — $1,500 per month," you have no idea what you’re buying. Site health matters, local rankings matter, conversions matter. Each one should be tracked and each one should be tied to a deliverable in the quote.
Let’s talk about blog content specifically, because this is where agencies get vague fast. When you see a line item for blog posts, it should specify how many posts per month, the target word count, and which keywords each post is built around. A common question I hear is: how many times should a target keyword repeat in a blog post? My answer — enough to be clear to the reader, not enough to feel robotic. That usually means your primary keyword appears in the title, the first paragraph, one or two subheadings, and then naturally throughout the body. There’s no magic number like "use it exactly seven times." What matters is that the agency has a documented approach and can show you the keyword map for each post before they write it. If the quote just says "four blog posts per month," ask for the keyword list. If they don’t have one ready, they’re writing content without a targeting plan.
Watch the language. Certain phrases in a quote almost always hide a lack of accountability: "ongoing optimization" with no deliverable count, "content strategy" with no post schedule, "link building" with no monthly target or link type named, "reporting" without specifying which metrics, what frequency, and what format. Agencies that use this language aren’t necessarily dishonest. Some are just sloppy. But sloppy means you can’t hold them to anything, and that’s money at risk.
A quote isn’t just a list of things the agency will do. It should also tell you how you’ll know those things happened. A solid reporting section names the dashboard or tool, lists the metrics tracked, and gives you a delivery schedule. For an SEO engagement, I’d want to see site health score, organic keyword rankings, organic traffic, and conversions all reported together — not just traffic, not just rankings, all of them together — because rankings without conversions is a vanity metric. Ask the agency: does your dashboard show revenue impact or conversion data? If the answer is no, you’re flying blind on ROI.
The query data I pulled for this video includes a recurring question about how much a small business should spend on marketing each month. Here’s the honest answer: it depends on your revenue and your growth goal. A common industry ballpark is 5% to 10% of gross revenue for a business trying to maintain its position, and up to 15% for one trying to grow aggressively. I’m not going to invent a number and tell you it applies to your situation. What I will say is that once you have a number in mind, every line in the quote should connect to that budget in a traceable way. If you’re spending $2,000 a month and you can’t point to which line items are driving calls or form fills, that’s the problem the line item format solves.
Picture a typical garage door company doing about 80 calls a month. They’re on a retainer that bundles everything together for $1,800. When we break that into line items, here’s what often surfaces: local SEO management $600, two blog posts per month $400, Google Business Profile optimization $200, reporting and account management $300, link building $300. Now you can have a real conversation. Is two blog posts per month enough to move the needle given the competitive keywords in your market? Are those blog posts being built around specific keywords, or are they generic tips articles? Is the reporting actually showing you which calls came from organic versus paid? That conversation is impossible when everything is bundled. Line items create the questions. Good questions protect your budget.
When you have two quotes in front of you, line them up by category — SEO versus SEO, content versus content, reporting versus reporting — and look for three things. First, which quote has more specificity? The quote that names the number of keywords, posts, and reports is more accountable by design. Second, which quote connects deliverables to outcomes? Any agency can write blog posts. The question is whether those posts are targeting keywords your buyers actually search. Third, which quote tells you what success looks like? A serious agency puts a measurable goal in the agreement — rankings for named keywords, traffic to named pages, or calls from organic search. If one quote has all three and the other doesn’t, the decision is mostly made for you.
Before you sign anything, ask these questions out loud and watch how the agency responds. Can you give me the keyword list you’re targeting on my site? How many organic keywords will you actively track each month? What does your reporting dashboard show and how often do I get access? How do you decide when to refresh old blog content versus write new content? If I want to pause or cancel, what’s the notice period? The answers matter less than the speed and specificity of the response. An agency that knows their process answers these in under two minutes. An agency that gets defensive or vague is telling you something.
All of this — the keywords, the content, the reporting — only works if the foundation is right. The foundation is visibility. If Google can’t find and understand your site, no number of blog posts fixes that. No amount of keyword targeting works if your site has technical errors, slow load times, or a broken local presence. Before you sign a retainer, know where you stand. Get a visibility audit first. Know your site health score, your current ranking keywords, and your local presence gaps. Then look at the quote and ask whether the line items actually address what’s broken. That sequence changes everything. Audit first. Retainer second.
Go to seo.pushleads.com/audit or call 828-348-7686. We’ll run a free visibility teardown on your site. You’ll see exactly where you rank, what’s broken, and what a real line item proposal for your market should look like. No obligation, no sales pressure — just the numbers.
For the agency, it makes delivery predictable. A team that produces the same shape of work every month can hire, train, and quality-control against it. Fully custom scoping every client is how agencies end up delivering inconsistently.
For both parties, it makes the price comparable. You can’t shop three fully bespoke proposals against each other in any meaningful way.
So the existence of tiers isn’t the warning sign. What the tiers vary is.
Want more customers from Google & AI search?
Get a free SEO audit of your site — see exactly what to fix first.
What Tiering Usually Hides
Pull up almost any agency’s package page and compare the columns. In the great majority, what changes between tiers is quantity:
| Starter | Growth | Premium | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Blog posts / mo | 2 | 4 | 8 |
| Keywords tracked | 25 | 75 | 200 |
| Optimized pages / mo | 1 | 3 | 6 |
| Reporting | Monthly | Monthly | Monthly + call |
| Link building | — | 2 links | 5 links |
Notice what doesn’t change: the strategy. Every tier does the same activities in different amounts. That’s fine if your problem is “not enough of the right work.” It’s wrong if your problem is different work entirely.
Three specific things get hidden in this structure.
The diagnosis is skipped. A business whose site is technically broken and a business whose site is fine but has no content need different first moves. Both get sold four posts a month.
Fixed items are diluted. Technical maintenance, monitoring, and strategy tend to be identical across tiers even though they’re a fixed cost. Buy the top tier and you’re paying triple for the same monitoring — which is fine, but you should know it.
Keyword counts are theater. “200 keywords tracked” is a software setting, not work. Tracking is nearly free. A tier that upgrades you from 25 to 200 tracked keywords has upgraded a checkbox.
Three Questions That Expose a Thin Package
Ask these before you compare prices. They take ten minutes and they’re more diagnostic than any proposal document.
1. “What would you change about this package for my business specifically?”
A good answer names something concrete: your site’s biggest problem is that eleven of your service pages are competing with each other, so month one is consolidation, not new content. A weak answer restates the package. If the answer is “it’s already tailored,” the package is a template with your logo on it.
2. “Which line item in this tier would you drop if the budget were 20% lower?”
This forces a priority ranking. Anyone who has thought about your account can answer instantly. Anyone who hasn’t will say every element is essential — which means they don’t know which parts drive your results. Their answer also tells you what they consider the weakest line, which is useful information you weren’t going to get otherwise.
3. “What has to be true in 90 days for this to be working?”
You’re looking for a specific, checkable claim. Fifteen target keywords into the top twenty, GBP calls up 30%, and the four broken service pages fixed and indexed. If you get “SEO takes 6–12 months” with no interim checkpoints, you’ve bought a year of unfalsifiable work. Timelines being long doesn’t mean progress is unmeasurable.
Package Versus Custom Scope
Neither is universally better. Pick based on your situation.
A package is right when:
– Your site is in reasonable technical shape
– You’re in a common vertical the agency has done many times
– You mainly need consistent production
– Your budget is under about $3,000 a month, where custom scoping overhead isn’t worth it
Custom scope is right when:
– You have a known structural problem — a migration, a penalty, cannibalization, a replatform
– You operate multiple locations or unusual service-area geography
– You’ve already run a package elsewhere and plateaued
– Your business model is unusual enough that the standard playbook doesn’t map
The hybrid that works best in practice: a custom one-time project to fix what’s broken, then a package retainer for the steady-state work. Diagnose custom, deliver standard.
A Fair Comparison Worksheet
When you have two or three proposals, normalize them before you compare. Build this table:
| Element | Agency A | Agency B | Agency C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total monthly | |||
| One-time / setup fees | |||
| Content: posts × words | |||
| Pages built or rewritten | |||
| Link acquisition: count + whether URLs are disclosed | |||
| Technical work: named or vague | |||
| GBP / local work included | |||
| Paid media management fee (and % or flat) | |||
| Who does the work: role and location | |||
| Named 90-day checkpoint | |||
| Contract length + notice period | |||
| Ownership of accounts and content | |||
| Cost per blog post (derive it) | |||
| Cost of everything that isn’t content (derive it) |
The last two rows do most of the work. Divide the content allocation out of the retainer and see what’s left. If content is 80% of the price, you’re buying a content shop — which may be exactly right, but you should buy it knowingly and compare it against content shops, not full-service agencies.
What We Do Instead
We publish line-item pricing and scope from a short diagnostic rather than a tier chart. Not because packages are wrong — for plenty of businesses they’re the efficient answer — but because in our verticals the right first month varies too much. A restoration company with a fast site and no content needs the opposite of what a plumber with eleven overlapping service pages needs.
If a tier fits you, take it. Just make sure the tier was chosen after somebody looked at your site, not before.
Quick Recap
- Packages solve real problems for both sides; the issue is that tiers usually vary volume, not strategy.
- Keyword-count upgrades are a software setting, not work.
- Ask what they’d change for you, what they’d cut at 20% less budget, and what has to be true in 90 days.
- Packages suit sound sites in common verticals under about $3,000/mo. Custom suits structural problems and unusual geography.
- Normalize proposals into one table and derive cost per post and cost of everything else.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are cheaper packages always worse?
No — they’re smaller. The failure mode isn’t price, it’s mismatch: buying a content-heavy package when your problem is technical, or vice versa. A $1,200 package aimed at the right problem beats a $4,000 one aimed at the wrong one.
Should I start at the lowest tier and move up?
Usually yes, with one exception: if the diagnosis says something structural is broken, fix that first as a project regardless of tier. Ramping volume on a broken site multiplies the problem.
Why do packages so often include exactly four blog posts?
Weekly cadence is easy to staff and easy to sell. It’s a production convenience, not a research finding. Some businesses need eight posts; plenty need two posts and a fixed site.
Is it a red flag if an agency won’t publish package prices?
Not by itself. Some genuinely scope custom. It is a red flag if they won’t give you a line-item breakdown after scoping — that’s different from not publishing a rate card.
Can I negotiate inside a package?
Often, yes — usually by swapping rather than discounting. Trading two blog posts for a service page rebuild is a reasonable ask and a good test of flexibility.
Keep Reading
Want more customers from Google & AI search?
Get a free SEO audit of your site — see exactly what to fix first.
Your path · Digital Marketing
10 articles. About 120 minutes.
Want this done for you?
Scan your site. See the gaps. Decide with numbers.
- Rankings, Google Business Profile and site-speed teardown
- Report lands in your inbox in about a minute
- No obligation · 4.9 from 67 Google reviews
